I was listening to the
news today, when the commentator mentioned how a Kansas law maker wanted to
allow harder spanking in schools. The spanking should be good enough to leave a
mark. The question the commentator asked their listening audience if they
agreed or disagreed with this form of punishment.
My thought was
visceral. I believe in punishment or discipline but not physical punishment. If
anyone in a school ever spanked one of my grandchildren, I would go in, tear
out their heart, chew it, and spit it in their face. So, I guess you pretty
much figured out that I am against spanking. Leave this to the parents and how
dare any legislator think that this would be a good idea. Maybe there should be
a law where any time a legislator squanders the tax payers’ on unnecessary
items, they should have a ruler slapped across their knuckles where it leaves a
red mark or bruise.
Thinking about corporal
punishment in schools takes me back to when I was in grade school and was
taught by those wonderful religious nuns. You know those religious sisters; the
ones who could not get married to a man but really were married to Jesus. The
ones where you never saw a slip or their black nuns shoes scuffed up or any
piece of hair, escaping from their head piece. I remember how big they were,
tall, and mighty scary in their long black dresses with flowing head gear. I
especially remember the large black leather belt that cinched their clothes
tightly about them along with the yards of rosary beads that hung on their
belt. The only thing missing was a gun, plastic gloves, and a Taser.
I also remember that
they could get physical, beat the living daylights out of you. And when you
went home…your parents finished off where the nuns left off. But I also
remember some of the mean ones….the ones who actually used that leather belt to
administer their punishment to a student’s legs. I pitied the girls who made
that fatal error of wearing a skirt instead of slacks. I also remember the
welts that the belt left behind.
I had a 7th
grade nun who was a bit off balanced and loved using her leather belt. She also
broke her pointer in half over someone. But that didn’t stop her…Sr.
Mary-Whatever-Your-Name…tied the pointer to her yardstick and used it to stab
kids in the back if they annoyed her or they needed to be reprimanded.
Then there was the
sweet little Irish nun who weighed about 80 pounds. She slammed one of the boys
into the blackboard and broke it. Or the time she ripped off a girl’s blouse.
Hey…there are so many stories that I could throw out there. But I bet you have
at least one if you ever went to a Catholic school in the 50s and 60s.
Now there are not too
many women who are nuns. Maybe that is a good thing but then again if they are
still around, Thank God for Med Express.
Thank you for speaking about this. I started out in elementary schools, public and private (without nuns) and discipline was handled in a reasonable manner, which was effective.
ReplyDeleteThen I was sent to a school run by nuns. There was all kinds of excessive corporal punishment as well as humiliating kids such as forcing little kids who wet the bed (this was a boarding school) to wear their urine-soaked pajamas all day the day following the bedwetting. We're talking mostly 7 and 8 year old kids, who couldn't control their bladder. Any fool knows you're not going to pee in your bed on purpose. So they humiliated these kids, and you can just imagine how they were teased and bullied at school when this happened. Now these nuns are pretty old. Elderly people sometimes wet the bed by accident too. Can you imagine the reaction if someone in a nursing home was treated that way? I am not advocating this; I don't believe in revenge. The school was called Linton Hall Military School and I write about it in http://lintonhallmilitaryschool.blogspot.com
The children should have been taught to Behave; for if they had the NUNS would not have had to discipline them!
ReplyDeleteI hope the sadistic hitches all went to hell, they are all dead now thank god.
ReplyDeleteI am in favour of corporal punishment. It should be hard enough to leave marks. Welts and bruises. It should hurt. Today we cotton wool kids. There's a fear of pain. We accept bad behaviour. We tolerate it without consequences. Meanwhile teachers and other kids put up with the disruption. Later in life, those kids who never received any punishment and consequently never learned boundaries comit some offence and wham for the first time they do get consequences and end up in jail.
ReplyDeleteI get some kids in the past were abused but many others, myself included, got the occasional whipping, and that was a good thing.